Justice Division sues to block major sugar merger, warning of cost hikes and source chain strains


ATU Photos | The Graphic Lender | Getty Illustrations or photos

The Biden administration on Tuesday sued to block the proposed merger of two sugar business giants, arguing that that acquisition would erase levels of competition and elevate prices at a time when world-wide provide chains are by now under pressure.

The civil antitrust lawsuit, filed in federal court in Delaware, aims to cease the United States Sugar from buying Imperial Sugar. The firms are rivals in the “currently cozy” sugar industry, stated Jonathan Kanter, assistant attorney typical of the Justice Department’s Antitrust Division, in a press launch.

“This deal substantially lessens competitiveness at a time when world-wide offer chain issues presently threaten steady accessibility to critical commodities and goods,” Kanter additional.

U.S. Sugar is a Delaware company that is privately held and headquartered in Florida. Imperial Sugar is owned by Louis Dreyfus, a world wide agricultural conglomerate centered in the Netherlands. The deal is valued at about $315 million.

The firms did not promptly react to CNBC’s requests for comment on the DOJ lawsuit.

The DOJ’s newest intervention in a big marketplace offer provides to the Biden administration’s history of pushing for antitrust enforcement. President Joe Biden‘s initially year in the White Residence has been marked by getting aggressive techniques to combat company consolidation, like by signing a sweeping government purchase and by looking for to block or limit bargains and partnerships in industries ranging from food stuff to publishing to airways.

Earlier in November, the DOJ submitted a lawsuit seeking to block Penguin Random Residence from buying rival Simon & Schuster for virtually $2.18 billion.

The DOJ in September sued to block a regional partnership between American Airways and JetBlue Airways, alleging the alliance would minimize competition, lessen the good quality of company and generate up airfares. The carriers, which have argued that the partnership will assistance them superior compete versus Delta Air Strains and United Airways, on Monday requested a federal judge to dismiss the fit.

“Robust antitrust enforcement is an crucial pillar of the Justice Department’s dedication to guaranteeing economic option and fairness for all,” Legal professional General Merrick Garland reported in a press release Tuesday. “We will not wait to problem anticompetitive mergers that would damage American individuals and enterprises alike.”

U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland attends a information convention to announce that the Justice Department will file a lawsuit challenging a Georgia election legislation that imposes new limits on voting, at the Section of Justice in Washington, D.C., June 25, 2021.

Ken Cedeno | Reuters

The deal amongst U.S. Sugar and Imperial Sugar “would leave an overpowering greater part of refined sugar income throughout the Southeast in the hands of only two producers,” the DOJ push release claimed. Us citizens as a result “would pay out more for refined sugar, a substantial enter for lots of food items and beverages,” the DOJ explained.

As the earth recovers from the coronavirus pandemic and purchaser demand from customers increases, fears of offer chain bottlenecks and shortfalls are also on the increase across the economy.

The criticism suggests that if U.S. Sugar acquires Imperial, it would fold Imperial’s creation into that of United Sugars Corporation, a cooperative that sells the sugar developed by U.S. Sugar and 3 other refiners. That deal would depart just two companies, United and Domino, in management of almost 75% of sugar sales across the southeast U.S., “leaving wholesale customers in this area at the mercy of a cozy duopoly,” the complaint alleges.

“As a outcome, fragile offer chains would be further strained, and American people would pay back a lot more for sugar and many staple foodstuff and beverage items,” the lawsuit suggests.

“This is a easy case: the merger of two direct opponents that will outcome in a really concentrated current market and guide to greater prices for a item that is critical to our country’s food provide,” the criticism provides.

“Simply just place: this scenario is not a close connect with.”

— CNBC’s Leslie Josephs contributed to this report.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here